People argue endlessly about what qualifies as “real punk,” but whatever that elusive quality is, it was unmistakably in the air when The Menzingers returned to the stage for their first show in a few months at Mickey’s Black Box, presented by local promoter Big Fan Presents.
The night was split cleanly between two emotional centers, almost mirroring the band’s long-standing and seamless sharing of vocal duties between Greg Barnett and Tom May. Despite this being a “warm up” show for their upcoming tour later this year the night felt alive, urgent, and deeply communal.
What elevated the night beyond a standard retrospective was the crowd itself. The heart-clenching enthusiasm poured into every line of songs like “I Don’t Wanna Be An Asshole Anymore” transformed familiar lyrics into something newly powerful. The opening of the night hit heavier than expected with “America (You’re Freaking Me Out)” taking on an extra level of meaning in today’s political climate.
There’s something quietly radical about shining a light on painful moments simply to exorcise them, about telling our own stories through borrowed words and shared applause. That’s one of The Menzingers’ greatest strengths. Both vocalists sing with an everyman sincerity that invites listeners to project their own histories into the songs. Triumphs and tragedies alike land harder because they feel lived-in, familiar, and honest.
This show was also a reminder that spectacle isn’t a prerequisite for greatness. No flashy backdrops, no exaggerated showmanship – just a body of work that has stood the test of time and a genuine desire to connect with the people standing in front of the stage. By leaning into their own normality, The Menzingers build a bridge that feels personal rather than performative.
And, maybe that’s the real definition of a punk rock show: not rebellion for its own sake, but connection, endurance, and songs that still mean something when the lights come up.
The Menzingers Tour
Photos: Matt Christine / Rock Documented – Mickey’s Black Box
