Pink Floyd released the compilation A Collection of Great Dance Songs in the United Kingdom on November 23, 1981. Its six tracks covered a decade of the band’s catalog, but the record was more than a straightforward collection of familiar recordings. One song was rebuilt, two were edited specifically for the set, and the title made a joke out of the entire assignment.
The project began as a rarities collection before changing direction toward a best-of. Columbia wanted a single-LP release for the holiday market, according to Ultimate Classic Rock, which meant compressing music made for full albums into two vinyl sides. The finished sequence opened with “One of These Days” from Meddle, moved through “Money” and “Sheep,” then devoted its second side to “Shine On You Crazy Diamond,” “Wish You Were Here” and “Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2.”
That last song appeared in an edited form, giving the compact collection one of its most immediate moments. Its official video carries the imagery and performance footage associated with The Wall.
“Shine On You Crazy Diamond” presented a harder editing problem. The original composition had been spread across both sides of Wish You Were Here, but the compilation reduced it to less than 11 minutes by combining material from Parts I, II, IV and VII. “Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2” was also adjusted, while “Wish You Were Here” received light trimming. Those decisions let three expansive pieces share a side without turning the release into a double album.
“Money” required a different solution. Capitol, which controlled the earlier recording for the American market, declined to license it for Columbia’s compilation. David Gilmour responded by recording the song again with producer James Guthrie. Gilmour supplied the vocal and handled guitar, bass, keyboards and drums, while Dick Parry returned to play saxophone. The cash-register tape loop survived from the version on The Dark Side of the Moon, but the performance around it was new.
The replacement was deliberately close to the familiar recording, yet its guitar and saxophone solos, instrumental feel and longer running time made it identifiable. Rather than dropping one of Pink Floyd’s best-known songs, the label dispute created a separate studio performance available as part of this compilation.
The title carried its own dry punch line. Pink Floyd’s official album history describes A Collection of Great Dance Songs as an ironic name built around the obvious problem that the band’s music was not generally made for dancing. Hipgnosis extended the joke onto the sleeve with ballroom dancers physically tethered to the ground. Even the artwork refused to let them move.
Commercially, the compilation peaked at No. 37 in the United Kingdom and No. 31 on the Billboard 200. Pink Floyd Records returned it to LP and CD in 2016, keeping the unusual six-song configuration, the tailored edits and Gilmour’s 1981 recording of “Money” together as one distinct piece of the band’s catalog.


